Capture the citation first, dictate the holding, and check every pin cite before filing.

Dictating Case Law Notes begins with the citation, not with the impression the case made on you. Before you dictate a single note, record the full case name, the reporter citation, the court, the year, and the judge if the opinion identifies one. Add the docket number and the date of decision. Capture the citation in the same form the firm uses so a colleague can find the case without translating your shorthand. A note without a complete citation is a memory, not a research record, and a memory cannot be verified when the argument depends on it. The citation is the first line of every note, whatever else follows.
Read the case once before you dictate anything. On the first read, mark the passages that state the question, the holding, the reasoning, and the disposition. Do not stop to write; stopping turns a first read into a slow transcription and you lose the shape of the opinion. On the second read, dictate into the note file, using the marks to guide the order. Note the procedural posture, because a holding from an appellate court after trial carries a different weight from a holding on a preliminary motion. The first read is for understanding, the second for the record, and the order matters.
Set up the note template before the second read. Create fields for the citation, the procedural posture, the facts, the question, the holding, the reasoning, the useful quotations, the subsequent treatment, and your own assessment. Keep the template short enough to complete for every case; a template that takes an hour to fill will be abandoned after the third case. Add a field for the practice area and the issues the case addresses, so the note can be found later. A consistent template turns a pile of case notes into a searchable library, and it lets you compare cases on the same issue without rereading each opinion.
Prepare the working file in the app you use for research notes. Name the file with the case name and the year, and place it in the folder for the matter or the practice area. Keep the opinion, the cited authorities, and any secondary summary beside the note. Decide who reviews the note before it is relied on in a brief, and note the date of the review. If the case is likely to be cited in a filing, note the pin cites you expect to use. A prepared file with a consistent name and a review step keeps a research note from becoming an orphan document that no one can find.
Dictate the facts in a short, neutral summary. State who the parties are, what happened, and how the dispute reached the court. Keep the summary to the facts that the holding depends on, and note the facts the court treated as important. Avoid the parties' characterizations and the court's rhetorical flourishes. If the facts are complicated, use a numbered list. A neutral fact summary lets a later reader compare cases on similar facts without being led by one court's description. It also protects you from the common error of treating a fact the court mentioned in passing as if it were part of the holding.
Dictate the question and the holding as a matched pair. State the question in one sentence, then state the holding in one sentence that answers it. If the court decided more than one issue, number them and pair each question with its holding. Distinguish the holding from dicta by noting which statements were necessary to the result and which were observations along the way. A note that treats every sentence as a holding will overstate the case's authority and may mislead the reader who relies on it. The question-and-holding pair is the core of the note and the part a colleague will read first.
Dictate the reasoning in the order the court used. State the rule the court applied, the authorities it relied on, and the steps that took it from the rule to the result. Where the court distinguished a case, note the distinction. Where the court rejected an argument, note the reason. Keep the reasoning in your own words and mark any sentence that comes close to the court's language, so the distinction between summary and quotation stays clear. A reasoning summary that follows the court's own steps is easier to check and easier to use when you need to explain the case to a colleague or a judge.
Dictate the disposition and the practical significance. State what the court did: affirmed, reversed, remanded, or dismissed. Then state what the decision means for the kind of matter you are working on, and mark that as your assessment rather than the court's. If the decision changes the rule in your jurisdiction, say so. If it confirms an existing rule, say that too. Keep the assessment short and label it clearly. A note that ends with the disposition but no significance leaves the reader to do the work of connecting the case to the matter at hand, which is the work the note was supposed to save.
Dictate quotations sparingly and exactly. Choose the sentences that state the rule or the reasoning in language you could not improve, and quote them word for word. Record the page where the quotation appears, and for a long quotation record the page at the start and the end. Do not splice two passages with an ellipsis in a way that changes the meaning. Do not quote a sentence that the court was describing and rejecting. A short, accurate quotation is more persuasive than a long one, and a quote that can be checked in seconds is more useful to a colleague than a paraphrase that has to be trusted.
Record the pin cite for every proposition. A citation that points to the case as a whole is of little use when the reader needs the specific page for a sentence. Note the page and, where the reporter uses it, the footnote or the paragraph number. For an unpublished opinion, note the paragraph number or the slip opinion page. For a statute or a rule cited within the case, record the section. A note with accurate pin cites lets a brief drafter move from the note to the source in one step and reduces the risk that a proposition is attributed to a page that does not support it.
Check the citation form against the local rule before you file the note. Confirm the reporter abbreviation, the court designation, the year, and the parenthetical. If the firm uses a citation manager, enter the case there and let the manager format it. If the note will support a brief in another jurisdiction, confirm the local citation format. A note is often the source of a citation that appears in a filing, so an error in the note can propagate into a document that is read by a court. Accurate citation form in the note is part of the research, not a formatting afterthought.
Keep a separate quotation log for the cases you cite most. List the case, the page, the quotation, and the proposition it supports. Update the log when you find a new passage. When a colleague asks for the language behind a proposition, the log answers in seconds. The log also makes it easy to check whether a quotation has been used consistently across documents, and to catch a paraphrase that drifted from the original. Over time, a quotation log becomes one of the most useful research assets a practice group has, because it captures the language that actually persuaded a court.
Check whether the case is still good law before you rely on it. Look for later decisions that distinguish, limit, or overrule it, and for amendments to any statute it interpreted. Record the date of your check and the source. If a later case questions the reasoning without overruling it, note the question and the jurisdiction. A note that records the case without its subsequent treatment can lead a colleague to cite a rule that no longer applies. Voiskey helps during this pass: it is an AI voice typing app for macOS and Windows, and you press a shortcut, speak an update, and the text appears at the insertion point in the note. Download Voiskey before the treatment check and dictate updates directly into the file.
Record the open questions the case leaves. Note the issues the court did not decide, the factual situations it distinguished, and the questions a lower court will still have to resolve. Mark each as an open question rather than as a holding. These notes are valuable when a later matter presents a variation on the facts, because they tell you exactly where the authority runs out. A case note that records only what the court decided, and not what it left open, gives a false impression of completeness and may lead to an argument that the case does not actually support.
Record the relationship between this case and the other cases in your note file. Note the cases it follows, the cases it distinguishes, and the cases that distinguish it. Use the same labels you use in the index so the notes connect. If a line of authority is developing, note where this case sits in the sequence. A network of connected notes is far more useful than a set of isolated summaries, because it shows the shape of the law rather than a single point. The connections are often the most valuable part of the note when a new question arises.
Record the assessment and the confidence level. State whether you would rely on the case in a brief, and why. Note the weaknesses: a split among courts, a narrow holding, a factual setting that differs from your matter. Voiskey learns names, jargon, acronyms, and spelling preferences, which keeps case names and defined terms consistent across a long note file, and it adapts punctuation, formatting, and tone to the note. Download Voiskey when a practice group maintains a shared research library. An honest assessment saves a colleague from discovering the weakness after the brief is filed, when the cost of correction is much higher.
File each note where the next reader can find it. Use a consistent name, a consistent folder, and a consistent set of tags. Tag the note with the practice area, the jurisdiction, the year, and the issues it addresses. Add the case name and the citation to the index. A note that is well tagged can be found by someone who does not remember the case name, which is the usual condition when research is needed under time pressure. File the note the same day you write it, because a note that sits in a working folder is a note that will be lost when the matter closes.
Build an index that supports the way the practice group works. List the cases by issue, by jurisdiction, and by year. Add a short one-line description of each holding so a reader can decide whether to open the note. Keep the index current as notes are added or updated. If the group uses a shared drive or a research tool, put the index where everyone can reach it. An index that is a year out of date is worse than no index, because it gives false confidence. Assign an owner and a review date so the index stays useful.
Review the notes before reusing them in a new matter. Confirm the citation, the holding, and the subsequent treatment. A note written two years ago may be accurate as a summary and outdated as authority. Check for later decisions and for changes in the statute before anyone relies on the note. Update the note and record the date of the update. If the note is still accurate, say so and add the date. A note that carries a clear review date is a note a colleague can trust; a note with no date is a note that has to be re-researched from the beginning.
Review the routine for the next research project. Note which parts of the template were hard to complete, which citations caused trouble, and where the subsequent-treatment check found a change. Update the template and the index structure. If a particular practice area needs additional fields, add them. Keep a short lessons note with the research file for the next matter. Over several projects, a consistent template, accurate pin cites, and a maintained index turn case notes into a durable asset that the whole practice can rely on, rather than a set of personal reminders that disappear when the matter closes.
Voiskey is an AI voice typing app for the desktop. Press a shortcut, speak a note or a correction, and the text appears at the insertion point in your notes file. It removes filler words, stutters, false starts, and grammar slips, so a spoken correction lands as clean text. You still check every citation, pin cite, and quotation against the opinion before the note is relied on.
Yes. Voiskey learns names, jargon, acronyms, and spelling preferences, which helps when a note file repeats case names, reporter abbreviations, and defined terms across many entries. A citation manager and an index still fix the approved forms. The spoken draft reduces retyping, and the reviewer checks each entry against the opinion before the note is shared.
Press a shortcut and speak the facts, holding, and reasoning into the note template, and text appears at the insertion point. Voiskey removes filler words, stutters, and false starts and adapts punctuation and formatting. Polish is the pass where you check pin cites, quotations, and subsequent treatment. At up to 220+ words per minute, the routine produces a complete note for the research review.
Yes. Voiskey is system-level, so text appears at the insertion point in whatever app or text field holds the note. You speak entries directly into the research file and revise them in the same place, with no separate suite to open. The workflow is Speak-Polish-Type-Edit, so corrections land in the version that will be indexed and reused.

Download Voiskey for Mac and Windows and turn spoken research into precise, indexed case law notes.
Use it across macOS, Windows, iOS, and Android